Showing posts with label Big Lick Comic Con. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Big Lick Comic Con. Show all posts

Sold Under False Pretenses - Mike DeCarlo's Batman A Death In The Family Watercolor Painting


Original artwork isn't cheap. Depending on the artist a one-of-a-kind piece can fetch hundreds, thousands, hundreds of thousands, or in some cases, millions of dollars. That's why when buying an original piece, there's a level of trust that must be involved. As the seller, you have to trust that the buyer isn't going to mass produce your work, and profit off of reproduction prints. As the buyer, you have to trust that the artist is protecting your investment by not turning around and recreating it for someone else.

For those of you who recall, I went to Big Lick NOVA 2026 on May 30, 2026. It was there that I met Mike DeCarlo for the first time. At his table, he was selling original artwork, and among the numerous pieces was a fantastic watercolor showcasing the four covers of the fan favorite Batman story arc, A Death In The Family. The below to be specific.


I showed immediate interest in it, and Mike saw this, telling me that he was sure it would sell fast, and further stated it was one-of-a-kind. He then reinforced this by saying it was something he wouldn't be doing again.

At $400.00, it was a great asking price. For those of you unfamiliar with commission pieces from comic artists, these typically cost between $300 and $600 per character, and sometimes more. Mind you, that's usually for a pencil and ink job. Certainly not full color, and definitely not watercolor. This was poised as a once in a lifetime opportunity, and a major investment. One I couldn't pass up.

When I got home, I even found Mike's original Facebook post, where upon completing it, he listed it for sale. He reaffirmed in writing in this post how, "This is the one and only time I will recreate in full color the 4 part series."


The problem, as it would turn out, is that this statement wasn't true.

Fast forward to October 11, 2026. I don't know what led me to search for "Mike DeCarlo A Death In The Family Watercolor" on Google, but I did. Imagine my surprise when I came across a very familiar looking ebay listing.


How could this be? Was it a fake? Did someone go online, pull the image, alter the autographs on the bottom to include Mike DeCarlo and Jim Starlin's signatures? I read over the seller's description hoping that they'd confirm the item was merely a print, but alas, no. It was stated as an original recreation of the cover art by Mike DeCarlo.


I reached out to the seller, politely asking if they could tell me when and where they bought this, as I had purchased a similar piece, and that when I did, it was sold to me with the pretense that it was one-of-a-kind. The seller was polite, and prompt with a response.

Conversation referenced with the permission of the seller.

They said they had purchased theirs in June of 2026 at HeroesCon, also for $400.00, and under the same pretense that it was one-of-a-kind. Upon discovering that this was not the case they were unhappy and decided to sell the piece to recoup their money.

In the interim of receiving their response, I also Google searched an email address for Mike DeCarlo, something that turns out was easier to do than I thought possible. I took a screen grab of his Facebook post, and the seller's listing, specifically those included in this post, and forwarded them to him. I was polite, not wanting to show my entire hand right off the bat. I simply asked if the one on ebay was legitimate since it looked similar to one he had posted on his Facebook page.

Mike actually responded rather quickly.


He not only stated that it looked legit but then complained how insulting it was that someone would buy a piece from him only to then list it for an upcharge on ebay. He then stated that he often does two or three of the same work if it is well received. The icing on the cake was him offering to make me my own for $320.00.

I wanted to immediately start typing out a response but was speechless, shocked how Mike could be insulted by someone trying to profit off of his work, but oblivious to how fans of his work would feel buying artwork from him under false pretenses. My investment suddenly felt worthless, and that was incredibly disheartening. Further, it was insulting to me that he diminished its value himself by not only continuing to recreate it but then offering to do so again at a cheaper price than I had previously paid.

Still, I wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt. Maybe I misheard him when I bought the painting. I went back to his Facebook page multiple times. Had I simply misread it too? No. He truly stated, in writing, that this was a piece he wasn't going to recreate. Yet here it was. A listing from an ebay seller for the exact same thing, and an email directly from Mike going completely against that statement.

Look, I get it. Mike stating that the piece wouldn't be recreated isn't a binding legal agreement between me and him, though perhaps it should be. The title of my article is me being polite. Whether the piece I purchased was or wasn't the only existing original at the time, or that he recreated it later doesn't matter. What matters is that it was advertised as the only one to be in existence, both verbally, and on his Facebook page, and that simply isn't the case. That in and of itself is a lie, scamming fans, unscrupulous business, and wrong.

At the end of the day, many of the veteran artists of the comic industry aren't working on any active books. They get their money from signing books from the past at conventions, selling commission pieces, and original artwork. As such, it's all the more important that they have the trust of the comic book community, AKA, the fans who are essentially paying them. When things like this happen, that trust is gone. Further, it has a ripple effect, wherein I now feel that if Mike DeCarlo has done this, who else out there is doing the same thing?

While I will still continue to purchase commissions in my Peter Parker: Decisions series, I'm done buying other artwork from comic creators. They charge a lot of money, and with that transaction needs to be trust that my investment is being protected by the artist. I'm incredibly insulted that not only has this not been the case with my purchase from Mike, but that he is still actively offering to recreate the piece, and at a cheaper price.

I wish Mr. DeCarlo the best, and I still appreciate his work, but he is someone I will no longer be able to support financially at conventions. That trust is gone.

I didn't bother responding to his email. What's the point in fighting with him about it? The money is already spent, and the recreated piece(s) are already out there. What's done cannot be undone. So, what's to be gained from confrontation? There's no reason to directly engage with him over this, nor should anyone else harass him about it.

Instead use this post as a cautionary tale from me to you. What happened to me can happen to you, and if nothing else, I recommend you be careful if / when buying artwork. Whether it's a comic creator or local artist, you may want to consider taking steps to protect your investment, such as having written agreements. It seems excessive to have to do so, but if your goal is to not have value diminished, and / or truly have a one-of-a-kind piece, it might be the best course of action. Otherwise, all you have is the other person's word, and as you can see from the above, sometimes that doesn't mean much at all.

***UPDATE OCTOBER 24, 2026***

On October 12, 2026, the day after my email to him, Mike posted on his Facebook page, continuing to state his disapproval of people buying his artwork, only to turn around and sell it for a profit. He doesn't reference this particular piece, but it's not difficult to put the timeline together, and conclude this is not mere coincidental timing that he would take to his social media to post this.

Posted by Mike on his Facebook page on October 12, 2026

He further posted a photo "yesterday", which would be October 23, 2026, holding another reproduced piece that he stated was for someone who purchased the commission. At this point, that makes three confirmed identical pieces, two of which were sold as one-of-a-kind.

I still wish you the best, Mike.

I've removed the piece from where it once hung on my wall and will actively look to sell it as well at this point. Hopefully I will at least be able to recover what I spent.

Click "HERE" to go back to the home page. For more posts related to this one, please click the labels below.

Big Lick NOVA 2026: Part III - Convention Book, Commissions, And Other Purchases


Today wraps up my posts on Big Lick NOVA 2026. Admittedly, I've had to condense these down to just three posts, when I initially wanted to stretch this out to six or more. Ultimately, I had to go this route because when planning these posts out in correlation with my series of Christmas catalogs, which have been going live each Monday since January, well, I didn't leave myself enough room to extend these posts out. No worries. Though it's come at the cost of a preemptive post which shows the convention itself, along with the cosplayers there, I did manage to sneak a select few photos into last week's post.

As I wrapped up my day at Big Lick NOVA, I did so by first stopping at two additional artist tables. The first was Matt Slay.

Matt's someone who has been at pretty much every convention I've been to, but I never stop by to see him. Mainly because I don't own anything he's ever worked on. I started by having him sign my convention book and then grabbing a few prints from him.

What I will say is that Mr. Slay is a very friendly guy. He's appreciative of the fans of his work, so much so that he won't charge for his signature on books. For prints, he charges just $10.00, and if you want a commission from him, he only charges $40.00.

Next up was Laura Martin. Much like Matt, I didn't have any books she'd worked on to get signed. I'm also sorry to say that initially I almost didn't have her sign my convention book. It was only while waiting for Alex Saviuk to finish something that I asked. Much like Matt, she doesn't charge for her autograph.

I did hook up both of them, including several others in artist alley with a pack of Masters of the Universe gummies. When I gave a pack to Mr. Saviuk, he asked, "These aren't the kind of gummies that make you feel good, are they?" To which I said, "Well, I cried into them for an hour, but they were ultimately just sugar", to which Mrs. Martin laughed.


So, what about the old convention book? While it's been around the block, it actually didn't get taken to last year's Big Lick NOVA. Mainly because there was nobody at that convention that I was looking to get a signature on it from.

At the show, I added Mike DeCarlo, Patrick Olliffe, Matt Slay, and Laura Martin. However, because I've added so many signatures to it since I first brought it to a show, I thought it would be a good idea, mainly for myself, to have a reference in one place for everyone who's signed it. So, please bear with me, and even enjoy the below.


Art Suydam at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Jim Shooter at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Mark Waid at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Michael Golden at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Renee Witterstaetter at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Rick Leonardi at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Ron Marz at Big Lick NOVA 2023

Al Milgrom at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Alex Saviuk at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Bob Hall at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Bob McLeod at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Bob Wiacek at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Brian Michael Bendis at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Chris Claremont at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Howard Chaykin at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Jim Starlin at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Jon Bogdanove at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

José Luis García-López at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Judy Bogdanove at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Keith Williams at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Klaus Janson at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Loise Simonson at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Walt Simonson at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Art Adams at Awesome Con 2024

Jeph Loeb at Awesome Con 2024

Jim Salicrup at Awesome Con 2024

Joe Rubinstein at Awesome Con 2024

Guy Dorian Sr. at Big Lick NOVA 2024

Brett Breeding at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Scott Hanna at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Bart Sears at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Mike Grell at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Richard Case at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Ron Garney at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Patrick Olliffe at Big Lick NOVA 2026

Matt Slay at Big Lick NOVA 2026


Howard Mackie at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Jae Lee at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Pop Mhan at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Terry Kavanagh at Baltimore Comic Con 2023

Mark Bagley at Awesome Con 2024

Christopher Priest (AKA Jim Owsley) at Big Lick NOVA 2024

Guy Dorian Jr. at Big Lick NOVA 2024

John Beatty at Big Lick NOVA 2024

Dan Jurgens at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Tom Bervort at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Billy Tucci at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Charles Vess at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Cully Hamner at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Denys Cowan at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

John Workman at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Josh Baylock at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Marc Hemper at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Ron Wilson at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Todd Dezago at Baltimore Comic Con 2025

Mike DeCarlo at Big Lick NOVA 2026

Lauren Martin at Big Lick NOVA 2026

Man, that could have been a post unto itself. Maybe it should have been.

After getting my convention book squared away, and making some other transactions (see below), I was off to walk the convention floor for some books I was after. Those included a second copy of Spider-Man number one, platinum edition, and Spider Noir issue one. Additionally, I went on the hunt for the Batman Returns and 1989 Toy Biz Joker from the McFarlane DC line. I struck out on everything. Nobody had a thing I was looking for. But I was determined to find something.

Comic wise, I picked up a couple Batman trades. The first was Batman: Ten Nights of the Beast. I actually got two copies of that, along with Batman: The Blue, The Grey, and the Bat. The seller gave them all to me for twenty bucks. The first I picked up because Mike DeCarlo was at the show, and I saw it as another signing opportunity. I ended up giving one of the copies to Russell, who was hanging out at Keith William's table after I got it signed. The second, I used to have back when I was a teenager.


Next up was Green Lantern Green Arrow issue 100. This was not a book on my list. Rather, after consistently striking out, I returned to Alex Saviuk's table and asked him what his first comic he ever worked on was. If you're a keen detective, you guessed it. This one. This issue is well loved but was in a series of bins marked three for $10.00.


Naturally, I was going to find a Spider-Man issue one to add to my ever-expanding collection. Though I wished it was the platinum edition. I got this one for $20.00, which is a bit more than I would normally pay for this book. However, people at the show seemed to be on whacky pills. I saw multiple variations of this book there, and people had donkey prices on them. In specific, one seller who had four different versions offered to sell them to me for $50.00 to $90.00 each. Get real!


I also added a few more McFarlane related books to my collection.

The first is Marvel Tales 235. It's nothing more than a reprint of Marvel Team-Up Annual 1, but the schtick is that it has a McFarlane cover. It's an important one to X-Men collectors because it's also the first time that he drew the characters for publication.

The middle book is an older Image Comics title, Darling Escapes. It appears to be from 1998, and came in two cover variants, the first being McFarlanes, and the second being Art Adams.

Lastly, I picked up a reprint of The Amazing Spider-Man issue 300. The schtick with this one is that it's printed in that retro 3D style with the blue and red inks and even includes a pair of unique glasses. I didn't need this book per se but picked it up from Joe of Pop-Up Comics after several failed, and at that point, comical attempts with him to find five different books.


Dracula Vs. King Arthur was a book that someone handed my girl from his table when she was taking photos. She mentioned she was getting them for my blog, and he gave it to her for free. I believe it was his that he worked on, but I honestly never got the chance to figure out all the details.


I wasn't necessarily looking to expand on my Marvel G.I. Joe collection, but these five were part of the bins labeled three for $10.00, and the only thing I could think of on a whim to add to the pile.


These two (below) were books I remember having as a kid, so it was cool to get these.


I did manage to find a couple figures to pick up.


I've actually come across the multi-signed Spider-Man figure before. In fact, it's what inspired me to get one, and get it signed. I got mine signed over a series of shows, with the most recent being Brett Breeding at Baltimore Comic Con 2025.

The one I bought at the show already included the signatures of Jim Shooter, Brett Breeding, and John Beatty, which my original also had. However, as an added bonus, it has the signatures of Michael Zeck, and Ron Frenz, who I've not had the opportunity to meet. I also added Rick Leonardi and Joe Rubinstein to it since they were at Big Lick NOVA 2026.


I also picked up a sweet Mega Man figure. It's one I'd looked at in the past, but never got around to adding to my video game figure collection.


Despite his minimal size, you can get him in quite a few poses. I mean, maybe. As you can see, I didn't really get all that creative with him. He also comes with multiple hands, and an additional head.

As noted above, I also picked up some prints from Matt Slay. He had so many different characters to choose from, and frankly, I'm sure I missed others I would have rather had. That's because as he sold out of a stack, he pulled out different things from a massive box.


Since he frequents shows, it shouldn't be a problem to get more at a later date. But candidly, while I framed these, I don't have them up on the wall. Space is really getting limited in that department.


Now we get into the gold. I'm talking the one-of-a-kind stuff. The expensive stuff, to put it bluntly. Since I couldn't find the books I was looking for, I reserved myself to do something that I wanted to do anyway but didn't know if I'd have the funds.

As I mentioned in my first post, the artist's tables were relatively empty. Which means all of them were available to do commissions, and happy to do so. I took full advantage of the opportunity to finally add new pieces to my Peter Parker: Decisions series.

One of the people I knew I wanted a commission from, and even mentioned it in the first post, was Mike DeCarlo. As I stated in that, he's known for his work on several cartoon classics. One of these is The Simpsons. Though it's not Peter Parker, I asked him to draw me Homer Simpson in this scenario. It turned out great!

Mike DeCarlo

I also really wanted to ask Alex Saviuk for a commission. Of all the ones I got, his was actually finished last, and well worth the wait.

Alex Saviuk

A pipe dream I was living in prior to the show was also adding one from Joe Rubinstein to the mix. I thought, "There's no way you're going to pull the above off, let alone adding that one too." Well, dreams do come true.

Joe Rubinstein

Finding out that Matt Slay only charged $40.00 for a commission, which with respect to everyone else, was far less expensive, I went ahead and got him in on the game as well.

I did feel bad for Mr. Slay because as I was picking up the commissions from those around him, he said, "I should have inked mine." I said that it was unfortunately too late, as it's already on its way home. That's because I had handed my heavy bag and drawings I had obtained to my girl, who was exhausted at that point, and wanted to head out. I didn't want to carry all of that around with me, so she took it home with her.

It coincided with George of G.I. Jigsaw texting me that he was coming to the show. So, I ask him if he could give me a ride home if she left, which he kindly agreed to do. He had bags of stuff in his hands when we left, so I'm sure he'll post something about the contents on his blog, if he hasn't already.

Matt Slay

Lastly, I went all in and got one from Patrick Olliffe as well.

Patrick Olliffe

While they didn't fit on my printer to really scan them in well, as you can see below, they look great on the wall. I Put them up in the order completed, but technically, if they were hung in the order they were asked for, it would go; Mike Decarlo, Alex Saviuk, Matt Slay, Joe Rubenstein, Patrick Olliffe.

Top Row / Left to Right
Rick Leonardi at Big Lick NOVA 2023
Jim Shooter at Big Lick NOVA 2023
Jim Salicrup at Awesome Con 2024

Middle Row / Left to Right
Keith Williams via email request
Mike DeCarlo at Big Lick NOVA 2026
Matt Slay at Big Lick NOVA 2026

Bottom Row / Left to Right
Patrick Olliffe at Big Lick NOVA 2026
Joe Rubenstein at Big Lick NOVA 2026
Alex Saviuk at Big Lick NOVA 2026

With Baltimore Comic Con 2026 on the horizon, I'm already working on my wish list for that show and even trying to make some arrangements in advance. We'll see what happens.

As I said in a prior post about the convention, this was my favorite I've ever attended. There were so many special memories attached to this one. Not only did I get a lot of great books signed, but I also got a lot of personalization out of it. You know what else though? I got to take my time and actually walk the showroom floor. That's something I often miss out on while jumping from line to line, essentially spending the day standing and waiting.

But guess what? It doesn't end there. Go all the way back to the first post in this series. Remember that watercolor painting Mike DeCarlo was holding up? Well, there's a reason he was.


While standing at his table as he signed my books, I started perusing through his portfolio. When I flipped the page to his cover collage of A Death In The Family, my jaw hit the ground. It was beautiful! When I told him as such, he said, "It could be yours."


Well, it is indeed.


It turns out that Mike posted this painting on his Facebook page just before the show, and while some people were expressing interest, I guess nobody pulled the trigger. Lucky me!


***IMPORTANT UPDATE***

Mike DeCarlo sold me the above painting under false pretense. He touted it as one-of-a-kind when I met him, and even stated this on his own Facebook page when he first completed the piece. However, this simply was not true. I would later find a seller on ebay with an identical painting created after I purchased mine, and a further confirmed third recreation on Mike's own Facebook page. That update is "HERE".
My day started by getting in line at 7:00 AM for doors that opened for early access attendees at 10:00 AM. I ended up staying at the show until 4:30 PM, which is when the final commission was completed. However, just prior to getting that last piece, I stopped at the table of Codakhrome Comic Shop.

Run by brothers JD Sutphin and Adam Sutphin, Codakhrome makes fantastic pieces of 3D artwork using actual comics. While I'm not sure which brother I ended up meeting on Saturday at the show, I did ask if he could make one for me based on McFarlane's Spider-Man number 1. To which he said he not only could, but that he'd have it by the next day. He texted me right around noon to inform me it was done, and confirm if I still wanted it, which I absolutely did.


When I got to the show, he said he'd actually been asked by multiple people if the piece was for sale. He did an absolutely amazing job on it, and I can see why people were inquiring.


I was hoping that along with these photos I could have included some shots my girl got from walking the convention. However, when I went through all of them, though she was thorough, she didn't get any. Despite this, please do check them out at the link above. The samples on their site of previous work are amazing, and who knows, maybe you want to commission a piece.

I hung it over my Spider-Man comic collection. It seemed the most appropriate space for it, and frankly, one of the few walls spaces left.


But with all of that, that truly does wrap up my annual visit to Big Lick NOVA. It was a blast! This one created so many memories that I'm sure I will cherish for a long time.

Click "HERE" to go back to the home page. For more posts related to this one, please click the labels below.